psiphon-tunnel-core/psiphon/controller.go

/*
 * Copyright (c) 2015, Psiphon Inc.
 * All rights reserved.
 *
 * This program is free software: you can redistribute it and/or modify
 * it under the terms of the GNU General Public License as published by
 * the Free Software Foundation, either version 3 of the License, or
 * (at your option) any later version.
 *
 * This program is distributed in the hope that it will be useful,
 * but WITHOUT ANY WARRANTY; without even the implied warranty of
 * MERCHANTABILITY or FITNESS FOR A PARTICULAR PURPOSE.  See the
 * GNU General Public License for more details.
 *
 * You should have received a copy of the GNU General Public License
 * along with this program.  If not, see <http://www.gnu.org/licenses/>.
 *
 */

// Package psiphon implements the core tunnel functionality of a Psiphon client.
// The main function is RunForever, which runs a Controller that obtains lists of
// servers, establishes tunnel connections, and runs local proxies through which
// tunneled traffic may be sent.
package psiphon

import (
	"context"
	"errors"
	"fmt"
	"math/rand"
	"net"
	"sync"
	"time"

	"github.com/Psiphon-Inc/goarista/monotime"
	"github.com/Psiphon-Labs/psiphon-tunnel-core/psiphon/common"
	"github.com/Psiphon-Labs/psiphon-tunnel-core/psiphon/common/protocol"
	"github.com/Psiphon-Labs/psiphon-tunnel-core/psiphon/common/tun"
)

// Controller is a tunnel lifecycle coordinator. It manages lists of servers to
// connect to; establishes and monitors tunnels; and runs local proxies which
// route traffic through the tunnels.
type Controller struct {
	config                             *Config
	sessionId                          string
	runCtx                             context.Context
	stopRunning                        context.CancelFunc
	runWaitGroup                       *sync.WaitGroup
	connectedTunnels                   chan *Tunnel
	failedTunnels                      chan *Tunnel
	tunnelMutex                        sync.Mutex
	establishedOnce                    bool
	tunnels                            []*Tunnel
	nextTunnel                         int
	startedConnectedReporter           bool
	isEstablishing                     bool
	concurrentEstablishTunnelsMutex    sync.Mutex
	concurrentEstablishTunnels         int
	concurrentMeekEstablishTunnels     int
	peakConcurrentEstablishTunnels     int
	peakConcurrentMeekEstablishTunnels int
	establishCtx                       context.Context
	stopEstablish                      context.CancelFunc
	establishWaitGroup                 *sync.WaitGroup
	candidateServerEntries             chan *candidateServerEntry
	untunneledDialConfig               *DialConfig
	splitTunnelClassifier              *SplitTunnelClassifier
	signalFetchCommonRemoteServerList  chan struct{}
	signalFetchObfuscatedServerLists   chan struct{}
	signalDownloadUpgrade              chan string
	impairedProtocolClassification     map[string]int
	signalReportConnected              chan struct{}
	serverAffinityDoneBroadcast        chan struct{}
	newClientVerificationPayload       chan string
	packetTunnelClient                 *tun.Client
	packetTunnelTransport              *PacketTunnelTransport
}

type candidateServerEntry struct {
	serverEntry                *protocol.ServerEntry
	isServerAffinityCandidate  bool
	adjustedEstablishStartTime monotime.Time
}

// NewController initializes a new controller.
func NewController(config *Config) (controller *Controller, err error) {

	// Needed by regen, at least
	rand.Seed(int64(time.Now().Nanosecond()))

	// The session ID for the Psiphon server API is used across all
	// tunnels established by the controller.
	NoticeSessionId(config.SessionID)

	untunneledDialConfig := &DialConfig{
		UpstreamProxyUrl:              config.UpstreamProxyUrl,
		CustomHeaders:                 config.CustomHeaders,
		DeviceBinder:                  config.DeviceBinder,
		DnsServerGetter:               config.DnsServerGetter,
		IPv6Synthesizer:               config.IPv6Synthesizer,
		UseIndistinguishableTLS:       config.UseIndistinguishableTLS,
		TrustedCACertificatesFilename: config.TrustedCACertificatesFilename,
		DeviceRegion:                  config.DeviceRegion,
	}

	controller = &Controller{
		config:       config,
		sessionId:    config.SessionID,
		runWaitGroup: new(sync.WaitGroup),
		// connectedTunnels and failedTunnels buffer sizes are large enough to
		// receive full pools of tunnels without blocking. Senders should not block.
		connectedTunnels:               make(chan *Tunnel, config.TunnelPoolSize),
		failedTunnels:                  make(chan *Tunnel, config.TunnelPoolSize),
		tunnels:                        make([]*Tunnel, 0),
		establishedOnce:                false,
		startedConnectedReporter:       false,
		isEstablishing:                 false,
		untunneledDialConfig:           untunneledDialConfig,
		impairedProtocolClassification: make(map[string]int),
		// TODO: Add a buffer of 1 so we don't miss a signal while receiver is
		// starting? Trade-off is potential back-to-back fetch remotes. As-is,
		// establish will eventually signal another fetch remote.
		signalFetchCommonRemoteServerList: make(chan struct{}),
		signalFetchObfuscatedServerLists:  make(chan struct{}),
		signalDownloadUpgrade:             make(chan string),
		signalReportConnected:             make(chan struct{}),
		// Buffer allows SetClientVerificationPayloadForActiveTunnels to submit one
		// new payload without blocking or dropping it.
		newClientVerificationPayload: make(chan string, 1),
	}

	controller.splitTunnelClassifier = NewSplitTunnelClassifier(config, controller)

	if config.PacketTunnelTunFileDescriptor > 0 {

		// Run a packet tunnel client. The lifetime of the tun.Client is the
		// lifetime of the Controller, so it exists across tunnel establishments
		// and reestablishments. The PacketTunnelTransport provides a layer
		// that presents a continuosuly existing transport to the tun.Client;
		// it's set to use new SSH channels after new SSH tunnel establishes.

		packetTunnelTransport := NewPacketTunnelTransport()

		packetTunnelClient, err := tun.NewClient(&tun.ClientConfig{
			Logger:            NoticeCommonLogger(),
			TunFileDescriptor: config.PacketTunnelTunFileDescriptor,
			Transport:         packetTunnelTransport,
		})
		if err != nil {
			return nil, common.ContextError(err)
		}

		controller.packetTunnelClient = packetTunnelClient
		controller.packetTunnelTransport = packetTunnelTransport
	}

	return controller, nil
}

// Run executes the controller. Run exits if a controller
// component fails or the parent context is canceled.
func (controller *Controller) Run(ctx context.Context) {

	ReportAvailableRegions()

	runCtx, stopRunning := context.WithCancel(ctx)
	defer stopRunning()

	controller.runCtx = runCtx
	controller.stopRunning = stopRunning

	// Start components

	// TODO: IPv6 support
	var listenIP string
	if controller.config.ListenInterface == "" {
		listenIP = "127.0.0.1"
	} else if controller.config.ListenInterface == "any" {
		listenIP = "0.0.0.0"
	} else {
		IPv4Address, _, err := common.GetInterfaceIPAddresses(controller.config.ListenInterface)
		if err == nil && IPv4Address == nil {
			err = fmt.Errorf("no IPv4 address for interface %s", controller.config.ListenInterface)
		}
		if err != nil {
			NoticeError("error getting listener IP: %s", err)
			return
		}
		listenIP = IPv4Address.String()
	}

	if !controller.config.DisableLocalSocksProxy {
		socksProxy, err := NewSocksProxy(controller.config, controller, listenIP)
		if err != nil {
			NoticeAlert("error initializing local SOCKS proxy: %s", err)
			return
		}
		defer socksProxy.Close()
	}

	if !controller.config.DisableLocalHTTPProxy {
		httpProxy, err := NewHttpProxy(controller.config, controller, listenIP)
		if err != nil {
			NoticeAlert("error initializing local HTTP proxy: %s", err)
			return
		}
		defer httpProxy.Close()
	}

	if !controller.config.DisableRemoteServerListFetcher {

		retryPeriod := time.Duration(
			*controller.config.FetchRemoteServerListRetryPeriodSeconds) * time.Second

		if controller.config.RemoteServerListURLs != nil {
			controller.runWaitGroup.Add(1)
			go controller.remoteServerListFetcher(
				"common",
				FetchCommonRemoteServerList,
				controller.signalFetchCommonRemoteServerList,
				retryPeriod,
				FETCH_REMOTE_SERVER_LIST_STALE_PERIOD)
		}

		if controller.config.ObfuscatedServerListRootURLs != nil {
			controller.runWaitGroup.Add(1)
			go controller.remoteServerListFetcher(
				"obfuscated",
				FetchObfuscatedServerLists,
				controller.signalFetchObfuscatedServerLists,
				retryPeriod,
				FETCH_REMOTE_SERVER_LIST_STALE_PERIOD)
		}
	}

	if controller.config.UpgradeDownloadURLs != nil {
		controller.runWaitGroup.Add(1)
		go controller.upgradeDownloader()
	}

	/// Note: the connected reporter isn't started until a tunnel is
	// established

	controller.runWaitGroup.Add(1)
	go controller.runTunnels()

	if *controller.config.EstablishTunnelTimeoutSeconds != 0 {
		controller.runWaitGroup.Add(1)
		go controller.establishTunnelWatcher()
	}

	if controller.packetTunnelClient != nil {
		controller.packetTunnelClient.Start()
	}

	// Wait while running

	<-controller.runCtx.Done()
	NoticeInfo("controller stopped")

	if controller.packetTunnelClient != nil {
		controller.packetTunnelClient.Stop()
	}

	// All workers -- runTunnels, establishment workers, and auxilliary
	// workers such as fetch remote server list and untunneled uprade
	// download -- operate with the controller run context and will all
	// be interrupted when the run context is done.

	controller.runWaitGroup.Wait()

	controller.splitTunnelClassifier.Shutdown()

	NoticeInfo("exiting controller")

	NoticeExiting()
}

// SignalComponentFailure notifies the controller that an associated component has failed.
// This will terminate the controller.
func (controller *Controller) SignalComponentFailure() {
	NoticeAlert("controller shutdown due to component failure")
	controller.stopRunning()
}

// SetClientVerificationPayloadForActiveTunnels sets the client verification
// payload that is to be sent in client verification requests to all established
// tunnels.
//
// Client verification is used to verify that the client is a
// valid Psiphon client, which will determine how the server treats
// the client traffic. The proof-of-validity is platform-specific
// and the payload is opaque to this function but assumed to be JSON.
//
// Since, in some cases, verification payload cannot be determined until
// after tunnel-core starts, the payload cannot be simply specified in
// the Config.
//
// SetClientVerificationPayloadForActiveTunnels will not block enqueuing a new verification
// payload. One new payload can be enqueued, after which additional payloads
// will be dropped if a payload is still enqueued.
func (controller *Controller) SetClientVerificationPayloadForActiveTunnels(clientVerificationPayload string) {
	select {
	case controller.newClientVerificationPayload <- clientVerificationPayload:
	default:
	}
}

// remoteServerListFetcher fetches an out-of-band list of server entries
// for more tunnel candidates. It fetches when signalled, with retries
// on failure.
func (controller *Controller) remoteServerListFetcher(
	name string,
	fetcher RemoteServerListFetcher,
	signal <-chan struct{},
	retryPeriod, stalePeriod time.Duration) {

	defer controller.runWaitGroup.Done()

	var lastFetchTime monotime.Time

fetcherLoop:
	for {
		// Wait for a signal before fetching
		select {
		case <-signal:
		case <-controller.runCtx.Done():
			break fetcherLoop
		}

		// Skip fetch entirely (i.e., send no request at all, even when ETag would save
		// on response size) when a recent fetch was successful
		if lastFetchTime != 0 &&
			lastFetchTime.Add(stalePeriod).After(monotime.Now()) {
			continue
		}

	retryLoop:
		for attempt := 0; ; attempt++ {
			// Don't attempt to fetch while there is no network connectivity,
			// to avoid alert notice noise.
			if !WaitForNetworkConnectivity(
				controller.runCtx,
				controller.config.NetworkConnectivityChecker) {
				break fetcherLoop
			}

			// Pick any active tunnel and make the next fetch attempt. If there's
			// no active tunnel, the untunneledDialConfig will be used.
			tunnel := controller.getNextActiveTunnel()

			err := fetcher(
				controller.runCtx,
				controller.config,
				attempt,
				tunnel,
				controller.untunneledDialConfig)

			if err == nil {
				lastFetchTime = monotime.Now()
				break retryLoop
			}

			NoticeAlert("failed to fetch %s remote server list: %s", name, err)

			timer := time.NewTimer(retryPeriod)
			select {
			case <-timer.C:
			case <-controller.runCtx.Done():
				timer.Stop()
				break fetcherLoop
			}
		}
	}

	NoticeInfo("exiting %s remote server list fetcher", name)
}

// establishTunnelWatcher terminates the controller if a tunnel
// has not been established in the configured time period. This
// is regardless of how many tunnels are presently active -- meaning
// that if an active tunnel was established and lost the controller
// is left running (to re-establish).
func (controller *Controller) establishTunnelWatcher() {
	defer controller.runWaitGroup.Done()

	timer := time.NewTimer(
		time.Duration(*controller.config.EstablishTunnelTimeoutSeconds) * time.Second)
	defer timer.Stop()

	select {
	case <-timer.C:
		if !controller.hasEstablishedOnce() {
			NoticeAlert("failed to establish tunnel before timeout")
			controller.SignalComponentFailure()
		}
	case <-controller.runCtx.Done():
	}

	NoticeInfo("exiting establish tunnel watcher")
}

// connectedReporter sends periodic "connected" requests to the Psiphon API.
// These requests are for server-side unique user stats calculation. See the
// comment in DoConnectedRequest for a description of the request mechanism.
// To ensure we don't over- or under-count unique users, only one connected
// request is made across all simultaneous multi-tunnels; and the connected
// request is repeated periodically for very long-lived tunnels.
// The signalReportConnected mechanism is used to trigger another connected
// request immediately after a reconnect.
func (controller *Controller) connectedReporter() {
	defer controller.runWaitGroup.Done()
loop:
	for {

		// Pick any active tunnel and make the next connected request. No error
		// is logged if there's no active tunnel, as that's not an unexpected condition.
		reported := false
		tunnel := controller.getNextActiveTunnel()
		if tunnel != nil {
			err := tunnel.serverContext.DoConnectedRequest()
			if err == nil {
				reported = true
			} else {
				NoticeAlert("failed to make connected request: %s", err)
			}
		}

		// Schedule the next connected request and wait.
		var duration time.Duration
		if reported {
			duration = PSIPHON_API_CONNECTED_REQUEST_PERIOD
		} else {
			duration = PSIPHON_API_CONNECTED_REQUEST_RETRY_PERIOD
		}
		timer := time.NewTimer(duration)
		doBreak := false
		select {
		case <-controller.signalReportConnected:
		case <-timer.C:
			// Make another connected request
		case <-controller.runCtx.Done():
			doBreak = true
		}
		timer.Stop()
		if doBreak {
			break loop
		}
	}

	NoticeInfo("exiting connected reporter")
}

func (controller *Controller) startOrSignalConnectedReporter() {
	// session is nil when DisableApi is set
	if controller.config.DisableApi {
		return
	}

	// Start the connected reporter after the first tunnel is established.
	// Concurrency note: only the runTunnels goroutine may access startedConnectedReporter.
	if !controller.startedConnectedReporter {
		controller.startedConnectedReporter = true
		controller.runWaitGroup.Add(1)
		go controller.connectedReporter()
	} else {
		select {
		case controller.signalReportConnected <- *new(struct{}):
		default:
		}
	}
}

// upgradeDownloader makes periodic attempts to complete a client upgrade
// download. DownloadUpgrade() is resumable, so each attempt has potential for
// getting closer to completion, even in conditions where the download or
// tunnel is repeatedly interrupted.
// An upgrade download is triggered by either a handshake response indicating
// that a new version is available; or after failing to connect, in which case
// it's useful to check, out-of-band, for an upgrade with new circumvention
// capabilities.
// Once the download operation completes successfully, the downloader exits
// and is not run again: either there is not a newer version, or the upgrade
// has been downloaded and is ready to be applied.
// We're assuming that the upgrade will be applied and the entire system
// restarted before another upgrade is to be downloaded.
//
// TODO: refactor upgrade downloader and remote server list fetcher to use
// common code (including the resumable download routines).
//
func (controller *Controller) upgradeDownloader() {
	defer controller.runWaitGroup.Done()

	var lastDownloadTime monotime.Time

downloadLoop:
	for {
		// Wait for a signal before downloading
		var handshakeVersion string
		select {
		case handshakeVersion = <-controller.signalDownloadUpgrade:
		case <-controller.runCtx.Done():
			break downloadLoop
		}

		// Unless handshake is explicitly advertizing a new version, skip
		// checking entirely when a recent download was successful.
		if handshakeVersion == "" &&
			lastDownloadTime != 0 &&
			lastDownloadTime.Add(DOWNLOAD_UPGRADE_STALE_PERIOD).After(monotime.Now()) {
			continue
		}

	retryLoop:
		for attempt := 0; ; attempt++ {
			// Don't attempt to download while there is no network connectivity,
			// to avoid alert notice noise.
			if !WaitForNetworkConnectivity(
				controller.runCtx,
				controller.config.NetworkConnectivityChecker) {
				break downloadLoop
			}

			// Pick any active tunnel and make the next download attempt. If there's
			// no active tunnel, the untunneledDialConfig will be used.
			tunnel := controller.getNextActiveTunnel()

			err := DownloadUpgrade(
				controller.runCtx,
				controller.config,
				attempt,
				handshakeVersion,
				tunnel,
				controller.untunneledDialConfig)

			if err == nil {
				lastDownloadTime = monotime.Now()
				break retryLoop
			}

			NoticeAlert("failed to download upgrade: %s", err)

			timer := time.NewTimer(
				time.Duration(*controller.config.DownloadUpgradeRetryPeriodSeconds) * time.Second)
			select {
			case <-timer.C:
			case <-controller.runCtx.Done():
				timer.Stop()
				break downloadLoop
			}
		}
	}

	NoticeInfo("exiting upgrade downloader")
}

// runTunnels is the controller tunnel management main loop. It starts and stops
// establishing tunnels based on the target tunnel pool size and the current size
// of the pool. Tunnels are established asynchronously using worker goroutines.
//
// When there are no server entries for the target region/protocol, the
// establishCandidateGenerator will yield no candidates and wait before
// trying again. In the meantime, a remote server entry fetch may supply
// valid candidates.
//
// When a tunnel is established, it's added to the active pool. The tunnel's
// operateTunnel goroutine monitors the tunnel.
//
// When a tunnel fails, it's removed from the pool and the establish process is
// restarted to fill the pool.
func (controller *Controller) runTunnels() {
	defer controller.runWaitGroup.Done()

	var clientVerificationPayload string

	// Start running

	controller.startEstablishing()
loop:
	for {
		select {
		case failedTunnel := <-controller.failedTunnels:
			NoticeAlert("tunnel failed: %s", failedTunnel.serverEntry.IpAddress)
			controller.terminateTunnel(failedTunnel)

			controller.classifyImpairedProtocol(failedTunnel)

			// Clear the reference to this tunnel before calling startEstablishing,
			// which will invoke a garbage collection.
			failedTunnel = nil

			// Concurrency note: only this goroutine may call startEstablishing/stopEstablishing,
			// which reference controller.isEstablishing.
			controller.startEstablishing()

		case connectedTunnel := <-controller.connectedTunnels:

			if controller.isImpairedProtocol(connectedTunnel.protocol) {

				// Protocol was classified as impaired while this tunnel established.
				// This is most likely to occur with TunnelPoolSize > 0. We log the
				// event but take no action. Discarding the tunnel would break the
				// impaired logic unless we did that (a) only if there are other
				// unimpaired protocols; (b) only during the first iteration of the
				// ESTABLISH_TUNNEL_WORK_TIME loop. By not discarding here, a true
				// impaired protocol may require an extra reconnect.

				NoticeAlert("connected tunnel with impaired protocol: %s", connectedTunnel.protocol)
			}

			// Tunnel establishment has two phases: connection and activation.
			//
			// Connection is run concurrently by the establishTunnelWorkers, to minimize
			// delay when it's not yet known which server and protocol will be available
			// and unblocked.
			//
			// Activation is run serially, here, to minimize the overhead of making a
			// handshake request and starting the operateTunnel management worker for a
			// tunnel which may be discarded.
			//
			// When the active tunnel will complete establishment, establishment is
			// stopped before activation. This interrupts all connecting tunnels and
			// garbage collects their memory. The purpose is to minimize memory
			// pressure when the handshake request is made. In the unlikely case that the
			// handshake fails, establishment is restarted.
			//
			// Any delays in stopEstablishing will delay the handshake for the last
			// active tunnel.
			//
			// In the typical case of TunnelPoolSize of 1, only a single handshake is
			// performed and the homepages notices file, when used, will not be modifed
			// after the NoticeTunnels(1) [i.e., connected] until NoticeTunnels(0) [i.e.,
			// disconnected]. For TunnelPoolSize > 1, serial handshakes only ensures that
			// each set of emitted NoticeHomepages is contiguous.

			active, outstanding := controller.numTunnels()

			// discardTunnel will be true here when already fully established.

			discardTunnel := (outstanding <= 0)
			isFirstTunnel := (active == 0)
			isLastTunnel := (outstanding == 1)

			if !discardTunnel {

				if isLastTunnel {
					controller.stopEstablishing()
				}

				err := connectedTunnel.Activate(controller.runCtx, controller)

				if err != nil {

					// Assume the Activate failed due to a broken tunnel connection,
					// currently the most likely case, and classify as impaired, as in
					// the failed tunnel case above.
					// TODO: distinguish between network and other errors
					controller.classifyImpairedProtocol(connectedTunnel)

					NoticeAlert("failed to activate %s: %s", connectedTunnel.serverEntry.IpAddress, err)
					discardTunnel = true
				} else {
					// It's unlikely that registerTunnel will fail, since only this goroutine
					// calls registerTunnel -- and after checking numTunnels; so failure is not
					// expected.
					if !controller.registerTunnel(connectedTunnel) {
						NoticeAlert("failed to register %s: %s", connectedTunnel.serverEntry.IpAddress)
						discardTunnel = true
					}
				}

				// May need to replace this tunnel
				if isLastTunnel && discardTunnel {
					controller.startEstablishing()
				}

			}

			if discardTunnel {
				controller.discardTunnel(connectedTunnel)

				// Clear the reference to this discarded tunnel and immediately run
				// a garbage collection to reclaim its memory.
				connectedTunnel = nil
				aggressiveGarbageCollection()

				// Skip the rest of this case
				break
			}

			NoticeActiveTunnel(
				connectedTunnel.serverEntry.IpAddress,
				connectedTunnel.protocol,
				connectedTunnel.serverEntry.SupportsSSHAPIRequests())

			if isFirstTunnel {

				// The split tunnel classifier is started once the first tunnel is
				// established. This first tunnel is passed in to be used to make
				// the routes data request.
				// A long-running controller may run while the host device is present
				// in different regions. In this case, we want the split tunnel logic
				// to switch to routes for new regions and not classify traffic based
				// on routes installed for older regions.
				// We assume that when regions change, the host network will also
				// change, and so all tunnels will fail and be re-established. Under
				// that assumption, the classifier will be re-Start()-ed here when
				// the region has changed.
				controller.splitTunnelClassifier.Start(connectedTunnel)

				// Signal a connected request on each 1st tunnel establishment. For
				// multi-tunnels, the session is connected as long as at least one
				// tunnel is established.
				controller.startOrSignalConnectedReporter()

				// If the handshake indicated that a new client version is available,
				// trigger an upgrade download.
				// Note: serverContext is nil when DisableApi is set
				if connectedTunnel.serverContext != nil &&
					connectedTunnel.serverContext.clientUpgradeVersion != "" {

					handshakeVersion := connectedTunnel.serverContext.clientUpgradeVersion
					select {
					case controller.signalDownloadUpgrade <- handshakeVersion:
					default:
					}
				}
			}

			// Set the new tunnel as the transport for the packet tunnel. The packet tunnel
			// client remains up when reestablishing, but no packets are relayed while there
			// is no connected tunnel. UseTunnel will establish a new packet tunnel SSH
			// channel over the new SSH tunnel and configure the packet tunnel client to use
			// the new SSH channel as its transport.
			//
			// Note: as is, this logic is suboptimal for TunnelPoolSize > 1, as this would
			// continuously initialize new packet tunnel sessions for each established
			// server. For now, config validation requires TunnelPoolSize == 1 when
			// the packet tunnel is used.

			if controller.packetTunnelTransport != nil {
				controller.packetTunnelTransport.UseTunnel(connectedTunnel)
			}

			// TODO: design issue -- might not be enough server entries with region/caps to ever fill tunnel slots;
			// possible solution is establish target MIN(CountServerEntries(region, protocol), TunnelPoolSize)
			if controller.isFullyEstablished() {
				controller.stopEstablishing()
			}

		case clientVerificationPayload = <-controller.newClientVerificationPayload:
			controller.setClientVerificationPayloadForActiveTunnels(clientVerificationPayload)

		case <-controller.runCtx.Done():
			break loop
		}
	}

	// Stop running

	controller.stopEstablishing()
	controller.terminateAllTunnels()

	// Drain tunnel channels
	close(controller.connectedTunnels)
	for tunnel := range controller.connectedTunnels {
		controller.discardTunnel(tunnel)
	}
	close(controller.failedTunnels)
	for tunnel := range controller.failedTunnels {
		controller.discardTunnel(tunnel)
	}

	NoticeInfo("exiting run tunnels")
}

// TerminateNextActiveTunnel is a support routine for
// test code that must terminate the active tunnel and
// restart establishing. This function is not guaranteed
// to be safe for use in other cases.
func (controller *Controller) TerminateNextActiveTunnel() {
	tunnel := controller.getNextActiveTunnel()
	if tunnel != nil {
		controller.SignalTunnelFailure(tunnel)
		NoticeInfo("terminated tunnel: %s", tunnel.serverEntry.IpAddress)
	}
}

// classifyImpairedProtocol tracks "impaired" protocol classifications for failed
// tunnels. A protocol is classified as impaired if a tunnel using that protocol
// fails, repeatedly, shortly after the start of the connection. During tunnel
// establishment, impaired protocols are briefly skipped.
//
// One purpose of this measure is to defend against an attack where the adversary,
// for example, tags an OSSH TCP connection as an "unidentified" protocol; allows
// it to connect; but then kills the underlying TCP connection after a short time.
// Since OSSH has less latency than other protocols that may bypass an "unidentified"
// filter, these other protocols might never be selected for use.
//
// Concurrency note: only the runTunnels() goroutine may call classifyImpairedProtocol
func (controller *Controller) classifyImpairedProtocol(failedTunnel *Tunnel) {

	// If the tunnel failed while activating, its establishedTime will be 0.

	if failedTunnel.establishedTime == 0 ||
		failedTunnel.establishedTime.Add(IMPAIRED_PROTOCOL_CLASSIFICATION_DURATION).After(monotime.Now()) {
		controller.impairedProtocolClassification[failedTunnel.protocol] += 1
	} else {
		controller.impairedProtocolClassification[failedTunnel.protocol] = 0
	}

	// Reset classification once all known protocols are classified as impaired, as
	// there is now no way to proceed with only unimpaired protocols. The network
	// situation (or attack) resulting in classification may not be protocol-specific.
	//
	// Note: with controller.config.TunnelProtocol set, this will always reset once
	// that protocol has reached IMPAIRED_PROTOCOL_CLASSIFICATION_THRESHOLD.
	if CountNonImpairedProtocols(
		controller.config.EgressRegion,
		controller.config.TunnelProtocol,
		controller.getImpairedProtocols()) == 0 {

		controller.impairedProtocolClassification = make(map[string]int)
	}
}

// getImpairedProtocols returns a list of protocols that have sufficient
// classifications to be considered impaired protocols.
//
// Concurrency note: only the runTunnels() goroutine may call getImpairedProtocols
func (controller *Controller) getImpairedProtocols() []string {
	NoticeImpairedProtocolClassification(controller.impairedProtocolClassification)
	impairedProtocols := make([]string, 0)
	for protocol, count := range controller.impairedProtocolClassification {
		if count >= IMPAIRED_PROTOCOL_CLASSIFICATION_THRESHOLD {
			impairedProtocols = append(impairedProtocols, protocol)
		}
	}
	return impairedProtocols
}

// isImpairedProtocol checks if the specified protocol is classified as impaired.
//
// Concurrency note: only the runTunnels() goroutine may call isImpairedProtocol
func (controller *Controller) isImpairedProtocol(protocol string) bool {
	count, ok := controller.impairedProtocolClassification[protocol]
	return ok && count >= IMPAIRED_PROTOCOL_CLASSIFICATION_THRESHOLD
}

// SignalSeededNewSLOK implements the TunnelOwner interface. This function
// is called by Tunnel.operateTunnel when the tunnel has received a new,
// previously unknown SLOK from the server. The Controller triggers an OSL
// fetch, as the new SLOK may be sufficient to access new OSLs.
func (controller *Controller) SignalSeededNewSLOK() {
	select {
	case controller.signalFetchObfuscatedServerLists <- *new(struct{}):
	default:
	}
}

// SignalTunnelFailure implements the TunnelOwner interface. This function
// is called by Tunnel.operateTunnel when the tunnel has detected that it
// has failed. The Controller will signal runTunnels to create a new
// tunnel and/or remove the tunnel from the list of active tunnels.
func (controller *Controller) SignalTunnelFailure(tunnel *Tunnel) {
	// Don't block. Assumes the receiver has a buffer large enough for
	// the typical number of operated tunnels. In case there's no room,
	// terminate the tunnel (runTunnels won't get a signal in this case,
	// but the tunnel will be removed from the list of active tunnels).
	select {
	case controller.failedTunnels <- tunnel:
	default:
		controller.terminateTunnel(tunnel)
	}
}

// discardTunnel disposes of a successful connection that is no longer required.
func (controller *Controller) discardTunnel(tunnel *Tunnel) {
	NoticeInfo("discard tunnel: %s", tunnel.serverEntry.IpAddress)
	// TODO: not calling PromoteServerEntry, since that would rank the
	// discarded tunnel before fully active tunnels. Can a discarded tunnel
	// be promoted (since it connects), but with lower rank than all active
	// tunnels?
	tunnel.Close(true)
}

// registerTunnel adds the connected tunnel to the pool of active tunnels
// which are candidates for port forwarding. Returns true if the pool has an
// empty slot and false if the pool is full (caller should discard the tunnel).
func (controller *Controller) registerTunnel(tunnel *Tunnel) bool {
	controller.tunnelMutex.Lock()
	defer controller.tunnelMutex.Unlock()
	if len(controller.tunnels) >= controller.config.TunnelPoolSize {
		return false
	}
	// Perform a final check just in case we've established
	// a duplicate connection.
	for _, activeTunnel := range controller.tunnels {
		if activeTunnel.serverEntry.IpAddress == tunnel.serverEntry.IpAddress {
			NoticeAlert("duplicate tunnel: %s", tunnel.serverEntry.IpAddress)
			return false
		}
	}
	controller.establishedOnce = true
	controller.tunnels = append(controller.tunnels, tunnel)
	NoticeTunnels(len(controller.tunnels))

	// Promote this successful tunnel to first rank so it's one
	// of the first candidates next time establish runs.
	// Connecting to a TargetServerEntry does not change the
	// ranking.
	if controller.config.TargetServerEntry == "" {
		PromoteServerEntry(tunnel.serverEntry.IpAddress)
	}

	return true
}

// hasEstablishedOnce indicates if at least one active tunnel has
// been established up to this point. This is regardeless of how many
// tunnels are presently active.
func (controller *Controller) hasEstablishedOnce() bool {
	controller.tunnelMutex.Lock()
	defer controller.tunnelMutex.Unlock()
	return controller.establishedOnce
}

// isFullyEstablished indicates if the pool of active tunnels is full.
func (controller *Controller) isFullyEstablished() bool {
	controller.tunnelMutex.Lock()
	defer controller.tunnelMutex.Unlock()
	return len(controller.tunnels) >= controller.config.TunnelPoolSize
}

// numTunnels returns the number of active and outstanding tunnels.
// Oustanding is the number of tunnels required to fill the pool of
// active tunnels.
func (controller *Controller) numTunnels() (int, int) {
	controller.tunnelMutex.Lock()
	defer controller.tunnelMutex.Unlock()
	active := len(controller.tunnels)
	outstanding := controller.config.TunnelPoolSize - len(controller.tunnels)
	return active, outstanding
}

// terminateTunnel removes a tunnel from the pool of active tunnels
// and closes the tunnel. The next-tunnel state used by getNextActiveTunnel
// is adjusted as required.
func (controller *Controller) terminateTunnel(tunnel *Tunnel) {
	controller.tunnelMutex.Lock()
	defer controller.tunnelMutex.Unlock()
	for index, activeTunnel := range controller.tunnels {
		if tunnel == activeTunnel {
			controller.tunnels = append(
				controller.tunnels[:index], controller.tunnels[index+1:]...)
			if controller.nextTunnel > index {
				controller.nextTunnel--
			}
			if controller.nextTunnel >= len(controller.tunnels) {
				controller.nextTunnel = 0
			}
			activeTunnel.Close(false)
			NoticeTunnels(len(controller.tunnels))
			break
		}
	}
}

// terminateAllTunnels empties the tunnel pool, closing all active tunnels.
// This is used when shutting down the controller.
func (controller *Controller) terminateAllTunnels() {
	controller.tunnelMutex.Lock()
	defer controller.tunnelMutex.Unlock()
	// Closing all tunnels in parallel. In an orderly shutdown, each tunnel
	// may take a few seconds to send a final status request. We only want
	// to wait as long as the single slowest tunnel.
	closeWaitGroup := new(sync.WaitGroup)
	closeWaitGroup.Add(len(controller.tunnels))
	for _, activeTunnel := range controller.tunnels {
		tunnel := activeTunnel
		go func() {
			defer closeWaitGroup.Done()
			tunnel.Close(false)
		}()
	}
	closeWaitGroup.Wait()
	controller.tunnels = make([]*Tunnel, 0)
	controller.nextTunnel = 0
	NoticeTunnels(len(controller.tunnels))
}

// getNextActiveTunnel returns the next tunnel from the pool of active
// tunnels. Currently, tunnel selection order is simple round-robin.
func (controller *Controller) getNextActiveTunnel() (tunnel *Tunnel) {
	controller.tunnelMutex.Lock()
	defer controller.tunnelMutex.Unlock()
	for i := len(controller.tunnels); i > 0; i-- {
		tunnel = controller.tunnels[controller.nextTunnel]
		controller.nextTunnel =
			(controller.nextTunnel + 1) % len(controller.tunnels)
		return tunnel
	}
	return nil
}

// isActiveTunnelServerEntry is used to check if there's already
// an existing tunnel to a candidate server.
func (controller *Controller) isActiveTunnelServerEntry(
	serverEntry *protocol.ServerEntry) bool {

	controller.tunnelMutex.Lock()
	defer controller.tunnelMutex.Unlock()
	for _, activeTunnel := range controller.tunnels {
		if activeTunnel.serverEntry.IpAddress == serverEntry.IpAddress {
			return true
		}
	}
	return false
}

// setClientVerificationPayloadForActiveTunnels triggers the client verification
// request for all active tunnels.
func (controller *Controller) setClientVerificationPayloadForActiveTunnels(
	clientVerificationPayload string) {

	controller.tunnelMutex.Lock()
	defer controller.tunnelMutex.Unlock()

	for _, activeTunnel := range controller.tunnels {
		activeTunnel.SetClientVerificationPayload(clientVerificationPayload)
	}
}

// Dial selects an active tunnel and establishes a port forward
// connection through the selected tunnel. Failure to connect is considered
// a port forward failure, for the purpose of monitoring tunnel health.
func (controller *Controller) Dial(
	remoteAddr string, alwaysTunnel bool, downstreamConn net.Conn) (conn net.Conn, err error) {

	tunnel := controller.getNextActiveTunnel()
	if tunnel == nil {
		return nil, common.ContextError(errors.New("no active tunnels"))
	}

	// Perform split tunnel classification when feature is enabled, and if the remote
	// address is classified as untunneled, dial directly.
	if !alwaysTunnel && controller.config.SplitTunnelDnsServer != "" {

		host, _, err := net.SplitHostPort(remoteAddr)
		if err != nil {
			return nil, common.ContextError(err)
		}

		// Note: a possible optimization, when split tunnel is active and IsUntunneled performs
		// a DNS resolution in order to make its classification, is to reuse that IP address in
		// the following Dials so they do not need to make their own resolutions. However, the
		// way this is currently implemented ensures that, e.g., DNS geo load balancing occurs
		// relative to the outbound network.

		if controller.splitTunnelClassifier.IsUntunneled(host) {
			return controller.DirectDial(remoteAddr)
		}
	}

	tunneledConn, err := tunnel.Dial(remoteAddr, alwaysTunnel, downstreamConn)
	if err != nil {
		return nil, common.ContextError(err)
	}

	return tunneledConn, nil
}

// DirectDial dials an untunneled TCP connection within the controller run context.
func (controller *Controller) DirectDial(remoteAddr string) (conn net.Conn, err error) {
	return DialTCP(controller.runCtx, remoteAddr, controller.untunneledDialConfig)
}

// startEstablishing creates a pool of worker goroutines which will
// attempt to establish tunnels to candidate servers. The candidates
// are generated by another goroutine.
func (controller *Controller) startEstablishing() {
	if controller.isEstablishing {
		return
	}
	NoticeInfo("start establishing")

	controller.concurrentEstablishTunnelsMutex.Lock()
	controller.concurrentEstablishTunnels = 0
	controller.concurrentMeekEstablishTunnels = 0
	controller.peakConcurrentEstablishTunnels = 0
	controller.peakConcurrentMeekEstablishTunnels = 0
	controller.concurrentEstablishTunnelsMutex.Unlock()

	aggressiveGarbageCollection()
	emitMemoryMetrics()

	// Note: the establish context cancelFunc, controller.stopEstablish,
	// is called in controller.stopEstablishing.

	controller.isEstablishing = true
	controller.establishCtx, controller.stopEstablish = context.WithCancel(controller.runCtx)
	controller.establishWaitGroup = new(sync.WaitGroup)
	controller.candidateServerEntries = make(chan *candidateServerEntry)

	// The server affinity mechanism attempts to favor the previously
	// used server when reconnecting. This is beneficial for user
	// applications which expect consistency in user IP address (for
	// example, a web site which prompts for additional user
	// authentication when the IP address changes).
	//
	// Only the very first server, as determined by
	// datastore.PromoteServerEntry(), is the server affinity candidate.
	// Concurrent connections attempts to many servers are launched
	// without delay, in case the affinity server connection fails.
	// While the affinity server connection is outstanding, when any
	// other connection is established, there is a short grace period
	// delay before delivering the established tunnel; this allows some
	// time for the affinity server connection to succeed first.
	// When the affinity server connection fails, any other established
	// tunnel is registered without delay.
	//
	// Note: the establishTunnelWorker that receives the affinity
	// candidate is solely resonsible for closing
	// controller.serverAffinityDoneBroadcast.
	//
	// Note: if config.EgressRegion or config.TunnelProtocol has changed
	// since the top server was promoted, the first server may not actually
	// be the last connected server.
	// TODO: should not favor the first server in this case
	controller.serverAffinityDoneBroadcast = make(chan struct{})

	for i := 0; i < controller.config.ConnectionWorkerPoolSize; i++ {
		controller.establishWaitGroup.Add(1)
		go controller.establishTunnelWorker()
	}

	controller.establishWaitGroup.Add(1)
	go controller.establishCandidateGenerator(
		controller.getImpairedProtocols())
}

// stopEstablishing signals the establish goroutines to stop and waits
// for the group to halt.
func (controller *Controller) stopEstablishing() {
	if !controller.isEstablishing {
		return
	}
	NoticeInfo("stop establishing")
	controller.stopEstablish()
	// Note: establishCandidateGenerator closes controller.candidateServerEntries
	// (as it may be sending to that channel).
	controller.establishWaitGroup.Wait()
	NoticeInfo("stopped establishing")

	controller.isEstablishing = false
	controller.establishCtx = nil
	controller.stopEstablish = nil
	controller.establishWaitGroup = nil
	controller.candidateServerEntries = nil
	controller.serverAffinityDoneBroadcast = nil

	controller.concurrentEstablishTunnelsMutex.Lock()
	peakConcurrent := controller.peakConcurrentEstablishTunnels
	peakConcurrentMeek := controller.peakConcurrentMeekEstablishTunnels
	controller.concurrentEstablishTunnels = 0
	controller.concurrentMeekEstablishTunnels = 0
	controller.peakConcurrentEstablishTunnels = 0
	controller.peakConcurrentMeekEstablishTunnels = 0
	controller.concurrentEstablishTunnelsMutex.Unlock()
	NoticeInfo("peak concurrent establish tunnels: %d", peakConcurrent)
	NoticeInfo("peak concurrent meek establish tunnels: %d", peakConcurrentMeek)

	emitMemoryMetrics()
	standardGarbageCollection()
}

// establishCandidateGenerator populates the candidate queue with server entries
// from the data store. Server entries are iterated in rank order, so that promoted
// servers with higher rank are priority candidates.
func (controller *Controller) establishCandidateGenerator(impairedProtocols []string) {
	defer controller.establishWaitGroup.Done()
	defer close(controller.candidateServerEntries)

	// establishStartTime is used to calculate and report the
	// client's tunnel establishment duration.
	//
	// networkWaitDuration is the elapsed time spent waiting
	// for network connectivity. This duration will be excluded
	// from reported tunnel establishment duration.
	establishStartTime := monotime.Now()
	var networkWaitDuration time.Duration

	iterator, err := NewServerEntryIterator(controller.config)
	if err != nil {
		NoticeAlert("failed to iterate over candidates: %s", err)
		controller.SignalComponentFailure()
		return
	}
	defer iterator.Close()

	isServerAffinityCandidate := true

	// TODO: reconcile server affinity scheme with multi-tunnel mode
	if controller.config.TunnelPoolSize > 1 {
		isServerAffinityCandidate = false
		close(controller.serverAffinityDoneBroadcast)
	}

loop:
	// Repeat until stopped
	for i := 0; ; i++ {

		networkWaitStartTime := monotime.Now()

		if !WaitForNetworkConnectivity(
			controller.establishCtx,
			controller.config.NetworkConnectivityChecker) {
			break loop
		}

		networkWaitDuration += monotime.Since(networkWaitStartTime)

		// Send each iterator server entry to the establish workers
		startTime := monotime.Now()
		for {
			serverEntry, err := iterator.Next()
			if err != nil {
				NoticeAlert("failed to get next candidate: %s", err)
				controller.SignalComponentFailure()
				break loop
			}
			if serverEntry == nil {
				// Completed this iteration
				break
			}

			if controller.config.TargetApiProtocol == protocol.PSIPHON_SSH_API_PROTOCOL &&
				!serverEntry.SupportsSSHAPIRequests() {
				continue
			}

			// Disable impaired protocols. This is only done for the
			// first iteration of the ESTABLISH_TUNNEL_WORK_TIME
			// loop since (a) one iteration should be sufficient to
			// evade the attack; (b) there's a good chance of false
			// positives (such as short tunnel durations due to network
			// hopping on a mobile device).
			// The edited serverEntry is temporary copy which is not
			// stored or reused.
			if i == 0 {
				serverEntry.DisableImpairedProtocols(impairedProtocols)
				if len(serverEntry.GetSupportedProtocols(false)) == 0 {
					// Skip this server entry, as it has no supported
					// protocols after disabling the impaired ones
					// TODO: modify ServerEntryIterator to skip these?
					continue
				}
			}

			// adjustedEstablishStartTime is establishStartTime shifted
			// to exclude time spent waiting for network connectivity.

			candidate := &candidateServerEntry{
				serverEntry:                serverEntry,
				isServerAffinityCandidate:  isServerAffinityCandidate,
				adjustedEstablishStartTime: establishStartTime.Add(networkWaitDuration),
			}

			wasServerAffinityCandidate := isServerAffinityCandidate

			// Note: there must be only one server affinity candidate, as it
			// closes the serverAffinityDoneBroadcast channel.
			isServerAffinityCandidate = false

			// TODO: here we could generate multiple candidates from the
			// server entry when there are many MeekFrontingAddresses.

			select {
			case controller.candidateServerEntries <- candidate:
			case <-controller.establishCtx.Done():
				break loop
			}

			if startTime.Add(ESTABLISH_TUNNEL_WORK_TIME).Before(monotime.Now()) {
				// Start over, after a brief pause, with a new shuffle of the server
				// entries, and potentially some newly fetched server entries.
				break
			}

			if wasServerAffinityCandidate {

				// Don't start the next candidate until either the server affinity
				// candidate has completed (success or failure) or is still working
				// and the grace period has elapsed.

				timer := time.NewTimer(ESTABLISH_TUNNEL_SERVER_AFFINITY_GRACE_PERIOD)
				select {
				case <-timer.C:
				case <-controller.serverAffinityDoneBroadcast:
				case <-controller.establishCtx.Done():
					timer.Stop()
					break loop
				}
				timer.Stop()
			} else if controller.config.StaggerConnectionWorkersMilliseconds != 0 {

				// Stagger concurrent connection workers.

				timer := time.NewTimer(time.Millisecond * time.Duration(
					controller.config.StaggerConnectionWorkersMilliseconds))
				select {
				case <-timer.C:
				case <-controller.establishCtx.Done():
					timer.Stop()
					break loop
				}
				timer.Stop()
			}
		}

		// Free up resources now, but don't reset until after the pause.
		iterator.Close()

		// Trigger a common remote server list fetch, since we may have failed
		// to connect with all known servers. Don't block sending signal, since
		// this signal may have already been sent.
		// Don't wait for fetch remote to succeed, since it may fail and
		// enter a retry loop and we're better off trying more known servers.
		// TODO: synchronize the fetch response, so it can be incorporated
		// into the server entry iterator as soon as available.
		select {
		case controller.signalFetchCommonRemoteServerList <- *new(struct{}):
		default:
		}

		// Trigger an OSL fetch in parallel. Both fetches are run in parallel
		// so that if one out of the common RLS and OSL set is large, it doesn't
		// doesn't entirely block fetching the other.
		select {
		case controller.signalFetchObfuscatedServerLists <- *new(struct{}):
		default:
		}

		// Trigger an out-of-band upgrade availability check and download.
		// Since we may have failed to connect, we may benefit from upgrading
		// to a new client version with new circumvention capabilities.
		select {
		case controller.signalDownloadUpgrade <- "":
		default:
		}

		// After a complete iteration of candidate servers, pause before iterating again.
		// This helps avoid some busy wait loop conditions, and also allows some time for
		// network conditions to change. Also allows for fetch remote to complete,
		// in typical conditions (it isn't strictly necessary to wait for this, there will
		// be more rounds if required).
		timer := time.NewTimer(
			time.Duration(*controller.config.EstablishTunnelPausePeriodSeconds) * time.Second)
		select {
		case <-timer.C:
			// Retry iterating
		case <-controller.establishCtx.Done():
			timer.Stop()
			break loop
		}
		timer.Stop()

		iterator.Reset()
	}
}

// establishTunnelWorker pulls candidates from the candidate queue, establishes
// a connection to the tunnel server, and delivers the connected tunnel to a channel.
func (controller *Controller) establishTunnelWorker() {
	defer controller.establishWaitGroup.Done()
loop:
	for candidateServerEntry := range controller.candidateServerEntries {
		// Note: don't receive from candidateServerEntries and isStopEstablishing
		// in the same select, since we want to prioritize receiving the stop signal
		if controller.isStopEstablishing() {
			break loop
		}

		// There may already be a tunnel to this candidate. If so, skip it.
		if controller.isActiveTunnelServerEntry(candidateServerEntry.serverEntry) {
			continue
		}

		// ConnectTunnel will allocate significant memory, so first attempt to
		// reclaim as much as possible.
		aggressiveGarbageCollection()

		// Select the tunnel protocol. Unless config.TunnelProtocol is set, the
		// selection will be made at random from protocols supported by the
		// server entry.
		//
		// When limiting concurrent meek connection workers, and at the limit,
		// do not select meek since otherwise the candidate must be skipped.
		//
		// If at the limit and unabled to select a non-meek protocol, skip the
		// candidate entirely and move on to the next. Since candidates are shuffled
		// it's probable that the next candidate is not meek. In this case, a
		// StaggerConnectionWorkersMilliseconds delay may still be incurred.

		excludeMeek := false
		controller.concurrentEstablishTunnelsMutex.Lock()
		if controller.config.LimitMeekConnectionWorkers > 0 &&
			controller.concurrentMeekEstablishTunnels >=
				controller.config.LimitMeekConnectionWorkers {
			excludeMeek = true
		}
		controller.concurrentEstablishTunnelsMutex.Unlock()

		selectedProtocol, err := selectProtocol(
			controller.config, candidateServerEntry.serverEntry, excludeMeek)

		if err == errProtocolNotSupported {
			// selectProtocol returns errProtocolNotSupported when excludeMeek
			// is set and the server entry only supports meek protocols.
			// Skip this candidate.
			continue
		}

		var tunnel *Tunnel
		if err == nil {

			isMeek := protocol.TunnelProtocolUsesMeek(selectedProtocol) ||
				protocol.TunnelProtocolUsesMeek(selectedProtocol)

			controller.concurrentEstablishTunnelsMutex.Lock()
			if isMeek {

				// Recheck the limit now that we know we're selecting meek and
				// adjusting concurrentMeekEstablishTunnels.
				if controller.config.LimitMeekConnectionWorkers > 0 &&
					controller.concurrentMeekEstablishTunnels >=
						controller.config.LimitMeekConnectionWorkers {

					// Skip this candidate.
					controller.concurrentEstablishTunnelsMutex.Unlock()
					continue
				}
				controller.concurrentMeekEstablishTunnels += 1
				if controller.concurrentMeekEstablishTunnels > controller.peakConcurrentMeekEstablishTunnels {
					controller.peakConcurrentMeekEstablishTunnels = controller.concurrentMeekEstablishTunnels
				}
			}
			controller.concurrentEstablishTunnels += 1
			if controller.concurrentEstablishTunnels > controller.peakConcurrentEstablishTunnels {
				controller.peakConcurrentEstablishTunnels = controller.concurrentEstablishTunnels
			}
			controller.concurrentEstablishTunnelsMutex.Unlock()

			tunnel, err = ConnectTunnel(
				controller.establishCtx,
				controller.config,
				controller.sessionId,
				candidateServerEntry.serverEntry,
				selectedProtocol,
				candidateServerEntry.adjustedEstablishStartTime)

			controller.concurrentEstablishTunnelsMutex.Lock()
			if isMeek {
				controller.concurrentMeekEstablishTunnels -= 1
			}
			controller.concurrentEstablishTunnels -= 1
			controller.concurrentEstablishTunnelsMutex.Unlock()
		}

		// Periodically emit memory metrics during the establishment cycle.
		if !controller.isStopEstablishing() {
			emitMemoryMetrics()
		}

		// Immediately reclaim memory allocated by the establishment. In the case
		// of failure, first clear the reference to the tunnel. In the case of
		// success, the garbage collection may still be effective as the initial
		// phases of some protocols involve significant memory allocation that
		// could now be reclaimed.
		if err != nil {
			tunnel = nil
		}

		aggressiveGarbageCollection()

		if err != nil {

			// Unblock other candidates immediately when
			// server affinity candidate fails.
			if candidateServerEntry.isServerAffinityCandidate {
				close(controller.serverAffinityDoneBroadcast)
			}

			// Before emitting error, check if establish interrupted, in which
			// case the error is noise.
			if controller.isStopEstablishing() {
				break loop
			}

			NoticeInfo("failed to connect to %s: %s", candidateServerEntry.serverEntry.IpAddress, err)
			continue
		}

		// Deliver connected tunnel.
		// Don't block. Assumes the receiver has a buffer large enough for
		// the number of desired tunnels. If there's no room, the tunnel must
		// not be required so it's discarded.
		select {
		case controller.connectedTunnels <- tunnel:
		default:
			controller.discardTunnel(tunnel)

			// Clear the reference to this discarded tunnel and immediately run
			// a garbage collection to reclaim its memory.
			tunnel = nil
			aggressiveGarbageCollection()
		}

		// Unblock other candidates only after delivering when
		// server affinity candidate succeeds.
		if candidateServerEntry.isServerAffinityCandidate {
			close(controller.serverAffinityDoneBroadcast)
		}
	}
}

func (controller *Controller) isStopEstablishing() bool {
	select {
	case <-controller.establishCtx.Done():
		return true
	default:
	}
	return false
}